Discipline Pt. 1: Outbursts


February 7, 2013 by sarahmortonisp

Outbursts. They’re frustrating, they’re distracting, they’re disruptive, and, according to 30+ year elementary school teacher Marti Schwartz, “Any teacher can be suddenly derailed by outrageous behavior,” and many times “we respond as human beings rather than wise educators.” 

Contrary to popular belief, Marti claims that offering students rewards such as stickers or other prizes was “often self-defeating” because it didn’t lead to her students “developing internal pride in work well done”. 

Marti found that encouraging positive behavior and having students write down their problems (later to be discussed calmly and asked “What happened?” and “What should I do next time?”) worked much better. “There are always problems” Marti claimed, “but I can honestly say that there were far less after I taught myself to always begin by looking for the positive. ” 

Instead of reprimanding children immediately, or holding stickers or candy over their heads; a teacher should be patient and try to figure out why there was a problem. 

This reminds me of a behavior technique B. F. Skinner–most famous for his “Skinner Box”–came up with: shaping. Shaping, as according to David G. Meyers’ 6th edition Psychology book, is “an operant conditioning procedure in which reinforcers guide behavior toward closer and closer approximations of a desired goal.” A reinforcer being “any event that strengthens the behavior it follows”, positive reinforcers are a much more positive method of dealing with outbursts than punishment–which, also according to Myers, does not get rid of behavior altogether and can “evoke undesired responses, such as anger, fear, or resistance.”  “Punished behavior is not forgotten;” Myers asserts, “it is suppressed.” 


2 thoughts on “Discipline Pt. 1: Outbursts

  1. Austin P. says:

    Hmm. I never thought of discipline in this manner before. I shall take this to mind if I am ever in a situation in which I need to control some younger fellows. Perhaps this will come in handy in 5th block Latin.

  2. sujkumar96 says:

    I found this very nice to read. I really liked the teacher’s perspective on outbursts I think that it would be really cool to figure out how many teachers around the world deal with these similar problems they face in the classroom and how they tailor their learning environment to lower the number of outbursts in the classroom. Great job!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: